Deciding on a Detergent
Monday, November 2nd, 2009Powder or liquid? This is an easy question for skiers to answer. But when it comes to laundry detergent, you have to wonder: is there a difference between powdered and liquid detergents? Aside from the obvious physical differences between the two, they appear to be identical. That’s my opinion (based on experience), for what it’s worth. Some disagree, claiming each type has specific advantages over the other. This is their argument (along with my interjections):
Pro Powdered Detergent
- Lower cost per load. If you divide the cost of the package (box or bottle) of detergent by the number of loads indicated on the package. This must be true, as powder detergent is typically cheaper.
- Ingredients in detergents, such as bleaching agents and surfactants, are more stable in powders and therefore have a longer shelf life than liquid detergents. Interesting, but who is concerned with detergent shelf-life? I suppose it would be smart to buy powders in bulk to save some money.
Pro Liquid Detergent
- Liquid detergents are pre-dissolved. If you have problems with getting your powdered detergent to dissolve (cold climates, hard water, etc.) a liquid detergent can resolve the problem. This is the best argument yet.
- Convenient for pre-treating stains: just dribble a little of the detergent on the stained area before placing the laundry in the washer. True, but a similar result can be had by mixing powdered detergent with water. Plus, the grittiness of the resulting solution may help remove stains.
If we really want to argue the advantages of each, I choose liquid detergent.


Candle wax on linens
Wine on the tablecloth
Gravy on linens



